Blog Post
Janie’s first experience with a relationship gave her a bleak outlook on the future of her love life. As a young girl, she was plucked out of believing a relationship should be about love, and forced into Nanny’s cynical, yet arguably realistic, ideal relationship with Logan Killicks. Being forced to do manual labor, being underappreciated, and not being attracted to Logan only further fueled Janie’s hopes for a better life. The culmination of these feelings led her to run off with Joe Starks, leaving Logan behind. One could view this as Janie simply taking advantage of Joe’s offer to get away from Logan’s harsh treatment of her, but this is probably not the case. Janie likes Joe’s ambition and confidence. However, over time as the initial spark starts to fade, Janie sees Joe’s true self, and does not like what she sees, nor how he treats her. Thus when he dies, Janie feels no remorse, and it is only cultural/societal pressures forcing her to pretend that she does. While promising at f...
Hey Ethan, this is a great post! You introduce your points very well and I like how you talk about how the narrator still hasn't fully developed his identity while at the Brotherhood and is almost being held back from doing so, which is odd considering how (seemingly) progressive they are. Good job.
ReplyDeleteYou do a nice job explicating how the narrator's seemingly more successful public identity with the Brotherhood still rests entirely on him manipulating (consciously or not) how others see him: one of his main measures of his success as a "leader" with the Brotherhood takes the form of him counting how many people said hi to him on the street on a given day. Is it *him* they are saying hi to, or his "Brotherhood identity"? It's impossible to separate them at this point--the only name they know him by was given to him by Jack. The narrator fleetingly feels that *he* is being "seen" on the streets of Harlem, but he's just performing a role. Anyone who fits the suit could do it, and the name isn't even his.
ReplyDeleteI really like your point about how the brotherhood hinders the development of the narrator in both physical and mental ways. I also liked your approach to discussing your thoughts regarding the novel. Great job!
ReplyDeleteEthan, I like how you raise the point that now that the narrator is alone he is truly able to find himself and be his own person. I think sometimes that can even make us reflect on how the people around us affect our personalities and our daily lives; sometimes we need a moment to back out and find our true selves. Nice post!
ReplyDeleteThis is a great post. The topic of the invisible man's identity development is definitely not linear, however, you do a good job of keeping a general timeline through your format to follow and it's greatly appreciated. I agree that it took breaking out from the Brotherhood and spending time alone and away from others for the invisible man to fully understand himself and his identity. Great job!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed how the first paragraph was blue. This was very unique. I really appreciate that color and found your creative choice very aesthetically pleasing. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDelete